Efficient hot water heater options

Choosing the most efficient hot water heater involves considering several factors, including your household's hot water needs, fuel type availability, upfront cost, and long-term energy savings. Here's a breakdown of the most efficient options:

​​

Top efficient hot water heater types
 

1. Heat Pump Water Heaters (HPWHs) / Hybrid Water Heaters:

   • How they work: These are considered the most efficient type of electric water heater. They don't generate heat directly, but rather extract heat from the surrounding air (like a refrigerator in reverse) and transfer it to the water in the tank. They often have an electric resistance backup for times of high demand.

   • Efficiency: An ENERGY STAR certified HPWH can use up to 50% less energy than a standard electric water heater. They are exceptionally efficient in mild climates where they can readily draw heat from the air.
      

   • Pros:

     • Highest energy efficiency among electric options.

     • Can save significantly on energy bills.

     • May qualify for tax incentives/rebates.

     • Can provide a small amount of cooling to the space they are in (e.g., basement), which can be a pro in summer.
        

   • Cons:

     • Higher upfront cost compared to traditional electric or gas tanks.

     • Require more space due to the heat pump unit and need good air circulation (not ideal for small, enclosed spaces).

     • Performance can be reduced in very cold climates.

     • Slightly shorter lifespan than tankless (10-15 years vs. 15-20 years for tankless).
        

   • Installation Cost: Average $3,200 - $4,700, but can range from $2,800 to $8,000 depending on type, size, and location.
      

2. Tankless Water Heaters (On-Demand Water Heaters):

   • How they work: Instead of storing hot water, tankless heaters heat water directly as it flows through the unit using a gas burner or electric element. This provides hot water on demand.

   • Efficiency: An ENERGY STAR certified tankless water heater can save you 30% more energy compared to standard storage tank types. They eliminate "standby heat loss" because they only heat water when needed.
      

   • Pros:

     • Highly energy-efficient, especially for homes with varying hot water needs.

     • Provide an endless supply of hot water (within their flow rate capacity).

     • Compact and save space, often wall-mounted.

     • Longer lifespan (15-20 years, sometimes up to 30 years for electric models) with proper maintenance.
        

   • Cons:

     • Higher upfront cost than conventional tank heaters.

     • Can have limitations on the amount of hot water they can provide at once (e.g., multiple showers running simultaneously might exceed capacity).

     • May require upgrades to gas lines or electrical systems, adding to installation costs.

     • Require periodic descaling to remove mineral deposits, especially with hard water.
        

   • Installation Cost: Average $1,200 - $3,500, but can range from $650 to $3,500 depending on fuel type (electric generally lower upfront) and complexity of installation (e.g., gas line or electrical panel upgrades).
      

3. Solar Water Heaters:

   • How they work: These systems harness the sun's energy to heat water. In Canada, they often preheat water alongside a backup conventional water heater (electric or gas).

   • Efficiency: ENERGY STAR certified solar water heaters can be up to 60% more energy efficient than standard storage water heater models.
      

   • Pros:

     • Extremely high energy savings from a renewable source.

     • Lower environmental impact.

     • Long lifespan.
        

   • Cons:

     • High upfront installation cost.

     • Performance is dependent on sunlight availability.

     • May require a backup system for cloudy days or high demand.

     • Often located outdoors, requiring antifreeze collectors in colder climates like Canada.
        

4. High-Efficiency Gas Storage Tank Water Heaters:

   • How they work: These are an improved version of the traditional storage tank heater, using advanced insulation and more efficient burners to reduce standby heat loss.

   • Efficiency: ENERGY STAR certified gas storage tank water heaters save about 9% more energy than standard gas models.
      

   • Pros:

     • More affordable upfront than tankless or heat pump models.

     • Provide a reliable supply of hot water.

     • Can be a good option if natural gas is readily available and you prefer a traditional tank.
        

   • Cons:

     • Still have standby heat loss, though reduced.

     • Less efficient than heat pump or tankless options.
        

Key factors to consider:

• Fuel type availability: Do you have natural gas lines, or is electricity your primary option? This heavily influences your choices.
   

• Household size and hot water demand:

  • Smaller households or homes with lower, intermittent hot water use: Tankless might be very efficient as they avoid standby loss.

  • Larger households with high, simultaneous hot water demands: Tankless systems need to be properly sized, or a heat pump with a large enough tank may be better suited.
     

• Climate: Heat pump water heaters are most efficient in mild-to-warm climates as they rely on ambient air. In very cold climates, their efficiency can decrease, and they may rely more on their electric resistance backup.
   

• Space availability: Tankless heaters are compact and can be wall-mounted, saving space. Heat pump water heaters are larger and require ample space with good air circulation.
   

• Upfront cost vs. long-term savings: More efficient models typically have a higher initial cost but offer significant long-term savings on energy bills. Consider the payback period.
   

• Installation complexity: Heat pump and tankless water heaters may require professional installation and potential upgrades to electrical panels or gas lines, which can add to the cost.
   

• Maintenance: Tankless heaters require periodic descaling, especially in areas with hard water, to maintain efficiency and longevity.
   

• Energy star certification: Always look for the ENERGY STAR label, as it indicates the unit meets strict energy efficiency guidelines.
   

Recommendation:

For the most efficient overall, considering both energy savings and long-term performance, a Heat Pump Water Heater is generally the top choice for electric systems, especially in suitable climates. If space is a major concern or you need truly endless hot water on demand and have a gas line, a Tankless Gas Water Heater is an excellent highly efficient option.
 

It's highly recommended to consult with a licensed plumber or HVAC professional in London, Ontario, as they can assess your specific home, hot water needs, and local regulations to provide the best recommendation and installation. They can also inform you about any available local rebates or incentives for energy-efficient appliances.